Strange New Worlds’ “Level-Five Transporter Accident” in Review

Spock must defend the Enterprise from Orion pirates, helped by a crew of puppets. Hijinks ensue! Is this Star Trek’s funniest episode?
Log Entry
Scotty’s planning to surprise his Academy nemesis Declan Milder by achieving a transporter record – beaming Milder the terrifying puppet “Little Ricky.” Spock visits La’an but she cancels their arrangements, feeling they’ve been separating since the Griffin incident. Pike is meanwhile excited about having a new touch-sensitive command chair. Spock struggles to meditate but eventually calls T’Pring. She offers to help him focus on logic, insisting on “no hijinks.” Spock is piloting a shuttle when T’Pring arrives. A transporter malfunction causes the entire crew and the Enterprise to briefly vanish. Spock returns to discover his shipmates have become puppets.

In the conference room, the puppets examine themselves. Ortegas and Pelia taunt Scotty about the screwup, Pelia expressing favoritism towards Declan Milder. The ship’s touch controls don’t recognize their puppet hands, leaving Spock the one individual able to operate the ship.
Calling April, Pike addresses the situation. April says help is two days away. Pike tries to grant Spock access to his fancy chair, but it won’t recognize Pike’s hands.
Scotty and Spock attempt to restore La’an using her buffer pattern, she having volunteered for the experiment. It fails, detaching one of her arms.

The arm isn’t painful and is reattached in sickbay. La’an realises Spock hasn’t talked to T’Pring since she’s become a puppet.
T’Pring is annoyed about the hijinks, even if they aren’t Spock’s fault. The entire crew needing his help, Spock gets so overwhelmed he has a panic attack, so she puppet-slaps him back to his senses. He thanks her, and she slaps him again!

Hailed by an Orion pirate ship, the puppets respond, audio only. Captain Ch’Rol introduces herself and feigns concern, seeing just one lifesign aboard. Uhura tries to hang up but turns on the viewscreen, revealing the puppet situation.
The Orions fire on the Enterprise, and the puppets panic. Spock manages to raise shields and fire torpedoes, but then he’s needed in engineering. Scotty is trapped under a torpedo but manages to release himself.

Since the Orions want to board the ship, Spock goes to confront them and encounters T’Pring with a bunch of phasers for him. She also has advice about the pirates’ strategy. Spock distracts them to protect her, but he’s immediately incapacitated.
The Orions tie Spock up in the mess hall and request the command codes. He refuses.

Trying to fight the Orions proves comically ineffectual. Captain Ch’Rol cuts Pelia in half. Pike is easily removed from his chair, and the puppets retreat. Ch’Rol considers them insignificant.
In Pike’s quarters, the puppets strategize. Chapel sews Pelia back together.
Spock’s Orion captor, Ejachi, seems quite affable and explains the merits of a matriarchal society. However, it turns out he was just distracting Spock.

Captured, Pike gets sent out the airlock. Spock and the crew are shocked and horrified. Pike survives, proving puppets are invulnerable to space.
The puppets embrace the absurd. They start with a three-puppets-in-a-trench-coat strategy. Scotty also invents a glove which gives them touch control, pleasing Pelia, who says Declan never actually impressed her.

Ejachi catches T’Pring trying to rescue Spock and culinary-torches her hand. She informs Spock that Pike is alive. Unharmed, T’Pring ignites Ejachi, unties Spock, and puppet-melds with him to relay information about Pike’s plan.
On the bridge, the puppets fight the Orion invaders. The mayhem makes Spock panic again, but T’Pring tells him the hijinks are the solution, not the problem. Taking her advice, Spock turns Pike into a projectile, distracting Captain Ch’Rol enough to slip into Pike’s chair. Ch’Rol demands the command codes, but he just stares her down, infuriating her. Pike reveals Spock isn’t speaking because he’s conserving oxygen since he deactivated life support on the bridge, and the Orions fall unconscious.
Spock wakes up in sickbay. Pike reveals Scotty can restore the crew, but first, they do a spacewalk.

Puppet T’Pring helps Spock meditate. They exchange romantic overtures.
Spock awakens in his quarters to find regular T’Pring staring at him. It turns out the whole thing was a strange dream, caused by a transporter accident that only involved him. Scotty has left Little Ricky in his quarters, horrifying Spock.

Status Report
This episode is a delightful mix of absurdity, genuine character development, and laugh-out-loud silliness. While the episode’s premise and Strange New Worlds’ overall reliance on gimmicks may perturb some viewers, the execution here is so fun it’s hard not to be glad it exists. The episode takes some big swings, but most of them connect. Even the normally tired Spock romance drama is almost enjoyable!

He’s the perfect straight man to contrast with the craziness of the puppets, and his struggle and overwhelm at trying to run the entire ship while surrounded by pirates and puppets is wonderfully acted by Ethan Peck. The rest of the cast does great with voicing their characters as puppets. In particular, Gia Sandhu as T’Pring nails the delivery of every line.
The puppet designs are hilarious; their likenesses are unmistakable, with unique features perfectly caricaturized. The Muppet-like looks matched by Muppet-like chaos are flawlessly executed, especially in the hysterical scene when they manage to retake the bridge. The physical comedy is unmatched, and the puppet physics are fun in the fight scenes. For anyone who enjoys this schtick, this might be one of Star Trek’s funniest episodes, especially for children. It continues Trek’s legacy as a family show, with something for everyone.

The ‘it was all a dream’ reveal may be an unsatisfying ending for some viewers. However, it’s effective at justifying the episode’s absurdity and frees the writers from having to conform the puppets to any reality-bound logic. It allows the audience to dismiss the technobabble and just have fun, while offering some solid character moments for Spock. While it’s arguable Strange New Worlds could have spent this time better elsewhere, this is one of the best episodes of the season so far.

Ren Wilcox is a Canadian YouTuber, artist, and lifelong Star Trek fan living in the US. They write film and produce reviews and video essays on various pop culture topics, but especially Star Trek on their YouTube channel Ren Rants and are currently working on a queer urban fantasy novel set in the Pacific Northwest. They have a bachelor’s degree in political science and a Juris Doctor, but their true passion lies in writing and other creative pursuits.